children looking through hole in barrier
End the Occupation

Criticizing the occupation and Israeli policies towards the Palestinians

Combat Unfair Attacks

Addressing unfair and inaccurate attacks from the far left

Two State Solution

Seeking a fair and just final status two-state solution to the Middle East conflict

Free Newsletter
Free Newsletter

Spotlights

Some Good News and Very Bad News

By TTNThe good news first: In the case that TTN’s Ken Bob wrote ...

Israel’s Arab Citizens Condemn Terror Attacks

By TTNThe following is taken from an article by Afif Abu Much in ...

Al-Walaja deserves a zoning plan, not home demolitions

By Kenneth BobI was standing upon a rooftop on a blustery cold Jerusalem day, ...

Progressives need to ‘punch’ in 2 directions

By Ralph SeligerDrawn in by a Haaretz alert about a lethal attack on Israelis ...

On Resuming Nuclear Deal with Iran

By TTNAfter suffering the enormous shock of suddenly losing his 19-year-old daughter Orli, ...

Firing of Anti-Zionist Hebrew School Teacher

By TTN BlogThis JTA article was brought to TTN’s attention a few weeks ago: ...

Disturbing Increase in Settler Violence

By Ralph SeligerOn Sunday, Feb. 13th, the Indiana University Institute for the Study of ...

Todd Gitlin Z”L (1943-2022)

By TTNWe remember one of our colleagues at The Third Narrative.  This links ...

Liberal Zionists on ‘Apartheid’ Report

By TTNThis is the statement issued by Ameinu, The Third Narrative’s sponsoring organization, ...

Debating Zionism as ‘Settler-Colonialism’

By Ralph SeligerOn Dec. 20th, Alan Johnson, editor of the British online journal, Fathom, ...

E-1 Settlement Construction Indefinitely Postponed!

By Ameinu OfficeAmeinu joins our Progressive Israel Network Colleagues in Welcoming Indefinite Postponement of Construction ...

Free Book: ‘The Case Against Academic Boycotts of Israel’

We are happy to offer a free PDF copy of the book “The ...

The Third Narrative Blog

MESA CHOOSES BDS OVER ACADEMIC FREEDOM

By Alliance for Academic Freedom

MIDDLE EAST STUDIES ASSOCIATION VIOLATES FUNDAMENTAL ACADEMIC FREEDOM PRINCIPLES WITH BDS ENDORSEMENT

The Alliance for Academic Freedom (AAF) condemns the March 24, 2022 vote by the Middle East Studies Association (MESA) to join the campaign of Boycotts, Divestment, and Sanctions (BDS) targeting the state of Israel. Academic freedom cannot exist where entire peoples or nations are effectively excommunicated from the global community of scholars and barred from the inherently collaborative work of research and teaching. By calling for an academic as well as cultural and economic boycotts of Israel, BDS restricts legitimate intellectual exchange with Israeli scholars, students, and institutions, and violates the most basic tenets of academic freedom; now, by endorsing BDS, MESA has embraced this violation. In doing so, it tramples on the rights of those who study or teach about the Middle East and North Africa, of all Israeli scholars and students, and of scholars around the world who collaborate with Israelis.

As we stated in our December 2021 statement on MESA, the organization itself had previously in 2005, through its own Committee on Academic Freedom, pointed to “the principles of academic freedom and the free exchange of information and ideas” as grounds for condemning academic boycotts such as BDS. At the time, MESA’s committee said, “We especially oppose penalizing entire segments of an academic community for any reason whatsoever.” That 2005 position was correct, we noted, because “free exchanges between faculty members and students worldwide are essential to the unfettered advancement of knowledge and to the viability of higher education.”

International research collaborations, international conferences, study-abroad programs, and peer review of publications and appointments are just a few among the many activities that inevitably entail international cooperation among individuals and institutions. To ostracize an entire nation, its people, and its educational institutions because of political disagreements is to discriminate on the basis of nationality, which in this case also has the effect of discriminating on the basis of ethnicity and religion.  

MESA’s abandonment of a principled position in favor of a politicized approach does not bode well for the organization, which in recent years has lost both institutional members and credibility in the eyes of many scholars. A professional society must be a home for scholars of all political persuasions.

As an organization, the AAF supports the national aspirations of Israelis and Palestinians alike. The full realization of those aspirations will come only with increased communication, interaction, and scholarly collaboration—not from the restriction of opportunities for such exchange.

On Behalf of the AAF Executive Committee: Susana Cavallo, David Greenberg, Rebecca Lesses, Jeffry Mallow, Sharon Musher, Cary Nelson (Chair), Kenneth Stern