children looking through hole in barrier
End the Occupation

Criticizing the occupation and Israeli policies towards the Palestinians

Combat Unfair Attacks

Addressing unfair and inaccurate attacks from the far left

Two State Solution

Seeking a fair and just final status two-state solution to the Middle East conflict

Free Newsletter
Free Newsletter

Spotlights

Open Letter to Members of SSSP

By Alliance for Academic FreedomAn Open Letter to Members of the Society for the Study of ...

Et Tu, Beinart? TTN Members Respond

By TTN BlogPeter Beinart’s recent NY Times op-ed and his longer essay in Jewish Currents argue in principle ...

Et Tu, Beinart?

By Ralph SeligerReligiously, Peter Beinart is what one may call “conservadox,” an observant Jew ...

In-Depth Look at Annexation

By TTN BlogCalev Ben-Dor, deputy editor of Fathom, the British online publication on Israel-related subjects, ...

The End of Labor Zionism?

By Ralph SeligerThis top photo of a 1950s-era MAPAM socialist-Zionist celebration of May Day ...

Progressive Jews Oppose Annexation

By Ameinu OfficeThe following is the May 14th statement of Ameinu (The Third Narrative’s ...

Is ‘Philo-Semitism’ Good for the Jews?

By TTNAn Iraq War veteran (of mixed Ashkenazi and Iraqi Jewish ancestry) and ...

Netanyahu-Gantz ‘Unity’

By TTNPerhaps it can be said that the Coronavirus crisis has claimed its ...

Founder of DSA Supported Zionism

By Mitchell CohenThis post borrows from a longer feature in Fathom, the British online ...

Contemporary Academic Antisemitism

By TTN BlogThis post selects from, and links to, an article in The Journal ...

Trump’s Plan vs. Geneva Initiative

By TTNOn Feb. 11, Yossi Beilin spoke at New York University’s Taub Center ...

Critique of Panel on Antisemitism

By Ralph SeligerThe Jewish Council for Public Affairs (JCPA) opened its first full day ...

The Third Narrative Blog

AAF DEPLORES ANTICIPATED ANNEXATION

By Alliance for Academic Freedom

The Alliance for Academic Freedom is deeply troubled by the Israeli government’s apparent intention in the near future to unilaterally annex substantial portions of the West Bank, possibly including both existing settlements and the Jordan Valley. Prime Minister Netanyahu’s winning of a new term and his post-election pronouncements about annexation point to a substantial territorial and political change that we expect will be disastrous for a democratic Israel and the Palestinian people and will have adverse consequences for the climate in academia in the United States.  

If implemented, unilateral annexation will exact a terrible price. It will make the possibility of a contiguous Palestinian state virtually impossible; that, in turn, would place a two-state solution out of reach for the near future and perhaps permanently. Unless Palestinians on the West Bank are granted full citizenship and equal rights in Israel proper – a highly improbable assumption – annexation will turn Israel into a state that maintains permanent control over millions of Palestinians within its territory while denying them civil and political rights. This will create an untenable situation for Palestinians as well as an indefensible position for a liberal democracy. The collapse of the Palestinian Authority and the growth of paramilitary groups on the West Bank, combined with greater Israeli governing responsibilities, might soon become a reality, heightening the chances of warfare and bloodshed. 

Under these circumstances, the AAF’s core mission – defending academic freedom as it relates to the Palestinian-Israel conflict amid a context of support for a two-state solution – would become increasingly difficult. As anger grows against a 53-year occupation whose end would be ever harder to envisage, we will likely see increased demands to boycott Israeli colleges and universities, and possibly other violations of academic freedom, such as disruptions of pro-Israel speakers. More generally, we can anticipate the derailing of collaborative solutions to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. 

For all these reasons, the AAF joins with many groups, including those in Israel and the Palestinian territories, to raise our voice in alarm at the possibility of annexation. We call on the Israeli government to pull back from a precipitous decision.

Executive Committee: Susana Cavallo, David Greenberg, Rebecca Lesses, Jeffry Mallow, Sharon Musher, Cary Nelson (Chair), Kenneth Stern