The World According to Salaita: ‘Zionism’ as Über-Oppressor
By Ameinu Office
Prof. John A. Shuler of the University of Illinois at Chicago has informed The Third Narrative community of an article by Dr. Steven Salaita, writing in The Nation following the recent settlement of his law suit. The article begins with the following italicized editorial introduction:
On November 12, Professor Steven Salaita settled his case against the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign (UIUC). In a victory for free speech, and for the activists both on and off campus who fought for it, the university agreed to pay $875,000, implicitly acknowledging its violation of Salaita’s academic freedom and the employment contract it signed with him. Salaita sued UIUC, along with the university’s Board of Trustees and top administrators, after the university fired him from his tenured position for tweeting comments critical of the Israeli government during its 2014 assault on Gaza. His case quickly became a symbol of both the intensifying crackdown on academic freedom and the suppression of Palestinian human rights advocacy—as well as the all-too-frequent overlap between the two. …
This quote from Dr. Salaita’s article encapsulates his conspiratorial view of “Zionism”:
Israel occupies imaginative in addition to physical geographies. Zionism therefore reproduces with great efficiency the cultures of recrimination in North America. It is necessary to connect this Zionist presence with the suppression of all radical ideas.
Palestinian human-rights activism, which often challenges Zionism, is firmly located in spaces of the political left, particularly among minority communities. Support for Israel, in contrast, exists in sites of authority, often an omnipresent but invisible accoutrement to swivel chairs, mineral water, and mahogany tables.
It’s not merely ideological Zionism that leads upper administration to support Israel—or, to be more precise, to entertain and normalize Zionist activism. Palestine solidarity represents democratization, grassroots organizing, anti-racism, and decolonization; it’s deeply involved in ethnic studies and other subversive fields. An upper administrator needn’t be amenable to West Bank settlement to understand the value of Zionism in his line of work.
. . . Zionism is part and parcel of unilateral administrative power. It lends itself to top-down decision-making, to suppression of anti-neoliberal activism, to restrictions on speech, to colonial governance, to corporatization and counterrevolution—in other words, Zionism behaves in universities precisely as it does in various geopolitical systems.
Prof. Shuler briefly reflects on this affair just concluded within his own university system:
What happened at the University of Illinois last summer was a terrible confluence of one individual’s protected but ill-considered free speech and advocacy, with an academic hiring process that is seriously flawed, conflated with long-standing problems that confront achieving true peace in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
The recent agreement that settled the court challenges between the University and Salaita does little more than sustain badly flawed advocacy and institutional policies. Salaita can continue to claim success as a survivor of a global Zionist conspiracy to silence him, while the University only conveys doubt that it can handle the next conflict between academic freedom and institutional goals any better. And the conflict in the Middle East remains unresolved.
We can do better.
Prof. Kenneth Waltzer of Michigan State University opines as follows:
The settlement maven Salaita announces his determination to continue to unsettle the world. For Salaita, that means finding Zionism in all places — behind efforts to suppress speech, lurking in university boardrooms on swivel chairs, lending itself to top-down decision-making, suppressing anti-neoliberal activism, embracing colonial governance, corporatization and counterrevolution. Zionism is everywhere, an unseen power, making the world go wrong, underwriting and supporting injustice. Those who question his bonafides or fitness to teach, who research his corpus or interpret his tweets, these too are “Zionist operatives,” part of the unseen power. Zionism explains all, Zionism is behind all. Salaita is a battler against all.
Regretfully, UI Urbana Champaign is free of him, but we are not. Something tells me this polemicist will haunt the searches for understanding and for peace for a long time.
Our TTN booklet responds to some of the most common and inaccurate accusations made against Israel from the far left by activists trying to appeal to those who are committed to human rights and social justice.
Scholars for Israel & Palestine (SIP) Pro-Israel, Pro-Palestine, Pro-Peace Scholars for Israel and Palestine comprises progressive academics who are pro-Israel, pro-Palestine, and pro-peace. We are committed to advancing a two-state solution to resolve the conflict between Israel and Palestine, bringing peace, justice and dignity to both sides. Click here for background, statements by the SIP and an application to join.
The Third Narrative engages with people on the left who suspect that it is wrong to lay all blame for the Arab-Israeli conflict at the feet of Israeli Jews but feel that too many Israel supporters reflexively support –or passively accept—the Israeli occupation. When it comes to this conflict, the truth is rarely black or white; it resides in a gray area where advocates on either side typically don’t like to venture.. » read more